By Blind Spot DriveBlog

Demand for Driving Instructors to Pass Learners Because of Test Backlog

Demand for Driving Instructors to Pass Learners Due to Driving Test Backlog

Outline:

1. Introduction
   • Overview of driving test suspensions and demand for alternatives.
2. The Current Driving Test Backlog
   • Explanation of the backlog situation and reasons behind it.
3. Why Are Learners Frustrated?
   • Exploring the frustrations of learner drivers due to delays.
4. Proposed Solution: Instructor-Based Passing System
   • Description of the suggested instructor-based system for passing learners.
5. Comparison to Predicted Grades for A Levels
   • Drawing a parallel between driving test proposals and school exam predictions during the pandemic.
6. Public Support and Petition
   • Overview of the petition and its growing support.
7. Arguments in Favor of the Instructor-Based System
   • Potential benefits of allowing instructors to pass students directly.
8. Concerns from the Driving Schools
   • Statements from major driving schools like Bill Plant and RED on the proposed system.
9. Road Safety and the Role of DVSA
   • How the current system is structured for safety and the DVSA’s role in maintaining standards.
10. The Institute of Advanced Motorists’ (IAM) Perspective
    • IAM’s concerns over lack of quality control in an instructor-based assessment model.
11. The DVSA’s Official Response
    • The agency’s response to the proposal and the reasons for not supporting it.
12. Proposed Solutions by the DVSA to Address Backlog
    • Overview of the DVSA’s measures to manage the test backlog.
13. Alternative Suggestions for Learners During the Wait
    • Tips and strategies for learners to stay prepared while waiting.
14. How Learners Can Stay Prepared
    • Practical tips for learners to keep their skills fresh and continue learning.
15. Conclusion
    • Summary of the current situation and the ongoing debate.
16. FAQs
    • Addressing common questions about the backlog, proposed changes, and next steps.

Demand for Driving Instructors to Pass Learners Due to Driving Test Backlog

Introduction

As driving test centers across the country face extensive backlogs, a new proposal has emerged that’s causing quite a stir: the idea of allowing driving instructors to directly pass learners they deem competent. With thousands of learners stuck in limbo, unable to schedule tests for months, many are questioning if there’s a better, faster way to get qualified drivers on the road.

The Current Driving Test Backlog

The driving test backlog has reached unprecedented levels. Due to lockdowns and restrictions from the COVID-19 pandemic, driving tests were suspended for extended periods, leading to a significant accumulation of pending test appointments. Learners who had prepared for months were suddenly left waiting indefinitely, causing widespread frustration.

Why Are Learners Frustrated?

For learner drivers, the inability to take a driving test means not only waiting to get on the road but also bearing the financial burden of extended lessons to maintain their skills. Some learners fear that the prolonged wait may result in skill erosion, requiring even more lessons to catch up. The lack of clear timelines for rebooking tests has left many wondering if there’s a way out.

Proposed Solution: Instructor-Based Passing System

In response to the backlog, a proposal has surfaced suggesting that qualified driving instructors should be allowed to pass students who they believe are road-ready. This idea is based on the premise that experienced instructors can fairly assess a learner’s competency, bypassing the need for an official test. Proponents believe this approach could quickly alleviate the backlog while still ensuring that only competent drivers receive licenses.

Comparison to Predicted Grades for A Levels

This proposal mirrors the approach taken with A Level students in 2020, where predicted grades were awarded by teachers due to canceled exams. Similarly, supporters of the instructor-based system argue that instructors, like teachers, are well-positioned to assess their students and make fair judgments on whether they’re test-ready.

Public Support and Petition

A petition supporting this idea has garnered over 50,000 signatures, demonstrating significant public interest in alternative methods for qualifying drivers. Many learners, instructors, and parents have voiced their support, hoping for a quicker path to getting licensed.

Arguments in Favor of the Instructor-Based System

Advocates of the instructor-based system argue that it could provide a practical, efficient solution to the backlog. By allowing instructors to sign off on a learner’s readiness, competent drivers could avoid months of waiting and start driving sooner. This system could reduce congestion in the test booking system and ease the strain on both learners and examiners.

Concerns from the Driving Schools

Not all driving schools are on board with this idea. Bill Plant Driving School, for example, has stated that while they empathize with learners’ frustrations, bypassing the official Driving and Vehicle Standards Agency (DVSA) process may compromise standards. Similarly, RED Driving School expressed concerns that removing the official examination might create a conflict of interest, potentially risking road safety.

Road Safety and the Role of DVSA

The DVSA’s primary mission is to ensure road safety by maintaining strict driving assessment standards. By having objective, trained examiners assess learners, the agency can enforce a uniform standard of competence. The DVSA argues that removing this standard could increase risks on the road, as instructors may be more lenient with their students.

The Institute of Advanced Motorists’ (IAM) Perspective

The IAM, also known as IAM RoadSmart, has voiced concerns about the lack of quality control in an instructor-based assessment system. According to the IAM, there’s currently no standardized way to evaluate feedback from Approved Driving Instructors (ADIs) to ensure it meets the rigorous standards of the practical driving test. While IAM sympathizes with learners, they believe the best course of action is to wait until testing can safely resume.

The DVSA’s Official Response

In response to the petition, the DVSA cited existing regulations that require specific qualifications for driving test examiners, who cannot also serve as active ADIs. The agency emphasized that while ADIs are highly qualified, they are not trained examiners, and statistics show that only about 47% of learners pass their test, which demonstrates the high standard required.

Proposed Solutions by the DVSA to Address Backlog

To tackle the backlog, the DVSA has outlined several measures, including:

• Offering Overtime and Annual Leave Buy-Back: Allowing examiners to work extra hours to increase test availability.
• Mobilizing Additional Examiners: Calling on all qualified individuals to assist with testing.
• Extended Hours and Holiday Testing: Expanding testing availability to include weekends and public holidays.

Alternative Suggestions for Learners During the Wait

While waiting, there are several ways learners can keep their skills sharp. Practicing essential skills and staying updated on road rules can make a significant difference when it’s time for the test.

How Learners Can Stay Prepared

1. Practice Essential Skills During Essential Trips: If possible, learners can practice driving on essential errands with a licensed adult in the vehicle.
2. Study the Highway Code: Staying up-to-date on road rules is crucial. Platforms like Theory Test Pro offer resources for continued learning.
3. Engage with Instructors Online: Many instructors offer virtual sessions where they provide tips and guidance to help learners maintain their skills.

Conclusion

The proposal to let instructors pass learners is a novel idea aimed at addressing the backlog crisis. However, road safety and consistency in testing standards are critical concerns. While this debate continues, learners should focus on preparing for the test as best as possible.

FAQs

1. Why is there a driving test backlog?
The backlog is primarily due to the COVID-19 lockdowns, which halted testing and created a significant accumulation of pending exams.

2. How does the instructor-based passing system work?
In this proposed system, instructors would assess and pass learners based on their skills, eliminating the need for a DVSA examiner.

3. Why do some driving schools oppose this proposal?
Driving schools like Bill Plant and RED Driving School are concerned that it may lead to conflicts of interest and compromise road safety.

4. What is the DVSA doing to manage the backlog?
The DVSA is expanding testing hours, allowing overtime, and mobilizing additional examiners to increase availability.

5. How can I stay prepared while waiting for my test?
Practice driving when possible, study the Highway Code, and stay in touch with your instructor for guidance on maintaining your skills.

Main image by Pinterest